Big Italy Pizzeria

Welcome to Big Italy Pizzeria

Welcome to Big Italy Pizzeria: A Slice of Tradition in Medford
Experience the true heart of Italy without ever leaving Medford, New York. At Big Italy Pizzeria, we don’t just serve food; we share a piece of our heritage. From the moment you walk through our doors, you’re greeted by the irresistible aroma of hand-tossed dough and simmering San Marzano tomatoes.

Passione Italiana Is Our Recipe

At Big Italy Pizzeria, our deep rooted love for Italian tradition is the heartbeat of every dish we serve. We are incredibly proud to be a local favorite in Medford, New York, a recognition that reflects our unwavering dedication to quality and our community. For us, making great food isn’t just a job it’s a craft centered on selecting the finest ingredients and honoring the time-tested techniques of the Old Country.

Cuore di Casa, Made with Heart

Big Italy Pizzeria's reputation is spreading through out the east coast. Big Italy has 8 top Restaurant reviews from some of the best media reviewers in Long Island and New York as being one of the BEST on Long Island.. Nightlife Magazine,& TV, New York Sportscene Magazine, Long Island Press, Dan's Papers. Penny Savor, Practical Gourmet Magazine, Ron Kapon, Writes for the New York Times, and appealed on Instagram, Facebook and Tik Tok by Gil from Avon Publishers.

READY TO ORDER?

Craving Big Italy? 🍕 Order for pickup or delivery and get a fresh, hot pie delivered straight to your door! 🚗

Check Out Our Pizzas

Check Out Our Main Menu

What our guests are saying

★★★★★

Big Italy Pizzeria is in my top three list of pizzerias on Long Island and in New York. Their Grandma pie is the best. When I go with my family, we order four personal pies made exactly the way we want and share a dinner. Plus, the inside has a warm, homely, antique décor.

Lucille